See full scan at the bottom of the page.

In the early years of the Cold War, at a time when anti-communist sentiment gripped the nation, a small pamphlet titled The Big Plot warned of a sweeping government plan to arrest tens of thousands of Americans “who appear to be acting in concert with Russian interests.”

Published by the National Non-Partisan Committee to Defend the Rights of the 12 Communist Leaders, the pamphlet both challenged and capitalized on widespread anxiety. Its bold imagery—a large noose encircling an outline of the United States, capturing diverse groups of Americans holding signs reading “Peace,” “Jobs,” “Civil Rights,” and more—offered a stark portrayal of how ordinary citizens might be caught in the dragnet of the Smith Act and other government policies targeting so-called “subversive” activity.

Historical Context

By 1950, Cold War tensions and domestic fears of Communist infiltration had peaked. Congressional hearings led by Senator Joseph McCarthy and various government agencies fueled suspicion that radical elements sought to undermine U.S. democracy from within. The Smith Act (officially the Alien Registration Act of 1940) criminalized advocating the violent overthrow of the government, enabling prosecutions of individuals accused of communist sympathies—even in cases where tangible evidence of violent conspiracy was limited.

One high-profile target was a group of Communist Party leaders, eventually referred to in the pamphlet as the “12 Communist Leaders,” who were indicted under the Smith Act. The trial and subsequent convictions aroused concerns among civil liberties advocates and anti-censorship organizations, many of whom feared that broader ideological repression was just around the corner. The Big Plot was crafted in direct response to these fears, seeking to alert the public to what it viewed as an unconstitutional erosion of freedom.

Strategy, Language, and Imagery

The front cover is a linocut-style illustration: a thick rope fashioned into a noose lassoing the entire map of the United States. Inside the rope, tiny figures hold signs with various demands or causes—“Rent Control,” “Civil Rights,” “Peace,” “Jobs,” “Union Shop,” “Farm Aid,” and more. This graphic approach communicates a clear message: that all types of reform-minded individuals, not just Communist Party members, might be ensnared under loosely defined “subversion” statutes.

• Alarm and Unity: By showcasing a wide variety of social and economic issues, the pamphlet implies that arrest under the Smith Act could extend to everyday Americans advocating for everything from wage increases to anti-war protests.
• Direct Accusation: The text repeatedly references official hearings and quotes government officials, framing the “21,105” figure as a stark proof of a “plan” in the making. The pamphlet’s language encourages readers to see themselves in the crosshairs, whether they identify as communist or simply criticize government policies.
• Defense of Constitutional Rights: Citing the Bill of Rights and First Amendment, The Big Plot frames anti-Smith Act advocacy as a patriotic stand against government overreach.

Efficacy and Public Reception

The Big Plot was primarily circulated within left-wing networks, civil liberties organizations, and labor circles. While it might not have swayed staunch anti-communists, it rallied a growing contingent of Americans worried about McCarthy-era blacklists, loyalty oaths, and prosecutions. By tying a wide range of grassroots causes to the fate of those accused under the Smith Act, the pamphlet offered a unifying, cautionary tale: if freedom of speech was restricted for one group, all groups risked losing their voice.

Like many pieces of political propaganda from this period, its effect was intensified by the very atmosphere of suspicion and censorship it sought to critique. For some, the pamphlet’s dramatic tone and imagery validated concerns that the federal government was overreaching. For others, it merely underscored what they already saw as communist fear-mongering.

Longer-Term Impact and Relevance

While McCarthyism ebbed by the mid-1950s, the issues raised by The Big Plot resonate with contemporary debates over surveillance, the scope of sedition laws, and the delicate balance between national security and individual freedoms. This pamphlet remains a historical artifact, documenting how fear can lead to broad crackdowns—and how protest materials can serve as both a rallying cry and a record of resistance.

The Big Plot reminds us that threats to civil liberties often extend beyond a single group, and that vigilance in defending free expression is an ongoing civic responsibility. Its stark cover image still speaks to modern audiences, capturing the tension between state power and grassroots activism that continues to shape American debate.

Special thanks to the USC Digital Imaging Lab for their support in digitizing this item.