Politically motivated counterfeiting
This is part of a series on nonviolent protest methods, which explains approaches and provides inspirational examples from history. For additional resources, please explore the Museum of Protest’s activist guides and view items in the collection.
Counterfeiting and document forgery have served as powerful tools of resistance throughout modern history, distinguished from criminal counterfeiting by their political rather than profit-driven motivations.
Gene Sharp catalogued counterfeiting as Method #90 in his foundational 198 Methods of Nonviolent Action, classifying it under “economic interventions” alongside strikes and selective patronage. This guide examines how resistance movements, anti-colonial struggles, and humanitarian networks have deployed counterfeiting strategically—destabilizing oppressive economies, funding liberation movements, and saving countless lives through forged papers that circumvented murderous bureaucracies.
The historical record reveals a clear pattern: politically motivated counterfeiting operates within broader resistance campaigns rather than in isolation, serves defined strategic objectives beyond personal enrichment, and often involves extraordinary personal sacrifice by participants who could face execution for their work.
Operation Bernhard: the largest counterfeiting operation in history
Nazi Germany executed history’s largest counterfeiting scheme between 1942 and 1945, producing £134.6 million in counterfeit British pounds—nearly 9 million banknotes of such quality that the Bank of England declared them “the most dangerous ever seen.” The operation demonstrates both the potential scale of state-sponsored economic warfare and the moral complexities inherent in weaponized counterfeiting.
SS Major Bernhard Krüger directed the operation from Blocks 18 and 19 at Sachsenhausen concentration camp, where 142 Jewish prisoners selected for skills in draftsmanship, engraving, printing, and banking were forced to produce the forgeries. The team successfully replicated rag paper with correct watermarks from the Hahnemühle factory, cracked the Bank of England’s serial number algorithm through cryptanalysis, and mastered the intricate “Bloody Britannia” engraving that protected British notes. At peak production, six flat-bed presses churned out 65,000 notes monthly.
The original plan called for dropping £30 billion over Britain to trigger hyperinflation and economic collapse. Strategic shifts redirected the notes toward intelligence funding: counterfeit pounds paid Turkish spy Elyesa Bazna (codename “Cicero”) for British secrets from the Ankara embassy and financed the September 1943 Gran Sasso raid that freed Mussolini. Friedrich Schwend laundered notes through a network of 50 agents operating from Schloss Labers in South Tyrol.
The Bank of England detected the first counterfeit in September 1943 at a British bank in Morocco—a duplicate serial number betrayed it. Britain responded by banning pound note imports, releasing emergency currency with metal security threads, and eventually withdrawing all notes larger than £5 from circulation. The post-war currency redesign took over a decade: new £5 notes appeared in February 1957, £10 returned in 1964, and £50 only in 1981.
Remarkably, Krüger was detained after the war but never charged—counterfeiting enemy currency was not considered a war crime. The Jewish prisoners survived because guards interpreted orders requiring all groups together before execution with unusual literality; American forces liberated them May 6, 1945. Remaining counterfeit notes, dumped into Austrian lakes, were recovered by divers in expeditions spanning 1959 through 2000. Adolf Burger’s memoir “The Devil’s Workshop” and the 2007 Oscar-winning film “The Counterfeiters” later documented this operation.
How Allied agencies weaponized forgery
The Allies developed their own sophisticated forgery infrastructure. Britain’s Special Operations Executive Station XIV at Briggens House near Roydon, Essex employed approximately 50 printers, draughtsmen, and Scotland Yard handwriting experts who produced over 275,000 forged documents during the war—passports, identity cards, ration cards, travel permits, driving licenses, and foreign currency notes.
Polish resistance fighters originally established the operation, including Jerzy Maciejewski, who forged Russian documents for the Polish underground. Staff smuggled real documents from occupied territories, copied them, and returned originals before discovery—on one occasion creating a forged French ration card the same day the genuine version was issued. Nazi analysis admitted the forged ration cards were “such deceitfully good copies that single coupons cut from them cannot be recognised immediately as forgeries.” As a morale-boosting joke, staff created a fake passport for Adolf Hitler listing his occupation as “painter” with a red “J” stamp and Palestine immigration stamp.
The American Office of Strategic Services established its Morale Operations Branch in March 1943 for “black propaganda,” producing forged German and Japanese identification cards, various passes and ration cards, and counterfeit currency including Japanese occupation currency for the Philippines and Burma, plus Chinese Reserve Bank notes. Operation Cornflakes (February 5, 1945) demonstrated creative application: P-38 fighter-bombers attacked a German mail train bound for Linz, then OSS agents dropped 8 mailbags of counterfeit letters and propaganda newspapers to be distributed by the German postal service itself. Letters bore forged postage stamps depicting Hitler’s face as a skull.
Adolfo Kaminsky: the forger who worked through the night
Among history’s most prolific resistance forgers, Adolfo Kaminsky (1925-2023) saved an estimated 10,000-14,000 Jewish lives during World War II alone—then continued forging documents for liberation movements for three decades afterward. His work exemplifies politically motivated forgery’s humanitarian applications and the personal costs involved.
Born in Buenos Aires to Russian Jewish parents, Kaminsky’s family moved to France where his mother was killed by Nazis in 1941. After his family’s internment at Drancy in 1943, Kaminsky joined the Jewish resistance group “La Sixième” at age 17 under the pseudonym “Julien Keller.” Working from a secret laboratory disguised as an artist’s studio at 17 rue des St Pères in Paris, he became the main producer of false identity documents for northern France and the Benelux countries.
His technical breakthrough came from earlier work at a dairy factory: he discovered that lactic acid could dissolve supposedly permanent Waterman blue ink, enabling alterations to existing documents. He mastered photogravure techniques to reproduce letterheads, watermarks, and rubber stamps, pressed his own paper, and duplicated official typefaces. His products included identity cards, passports, birth certificates, baptismal certificates, marriage certificates, and ration cards—replacing Jewish-sounding names with gentile alternatives.
In one critical mission, Kaminsky produced 900 documents in three days to save 300 Jewish children from deportation. He later explained his relentless pace: “In one hour I can make 30 blank documents. If I sleep for an hour 30 people will die.” The strain permanently damaged his right eye. He never accepted payment for any forgery work, maintaining that working for free preserved his freedom to refuse jobs he disagreed with.
After liberation, Kaminsky continued for three decades—helping Holocaust survivors reach Palestine via clandestine emigration networks, assisting the Algerian National Liberation Front (producing a cubic meter of counterfeit 100-franc notes, burned at ceasefire in March 1962), supporting anti-apartheid activists in South Africa, aiding Greek resistance against the Colonels’ regime, and making papers for American Vietnam War draft dodgers. His daughter Sarah Kaminsky published his biography in 2009, and he received the Croix du Combattant and Médaille de Vermeil de la ville de Paris.
The protective passport strategy
Swedish diplomat Raoul Wallenberg demonstrated how creatively designed documents could exploit bureaucratic psychology to save lives. Arriving in Budapest in July 1944 as Sweden’s special envoy, he designed the Schutzpass—a blue and yellow protective passport bearing the Swedish coat of arms that gave Jews status as Swedish subjects awaiting repatriation.
Wallenberg understood that Nazi and Hungarian bureaucrats had a “weakness for symbology”—official-looking documents commanded respect regardless of actual legal validity. While authorized to issue 4,500 passes, he distributed an estimated 13,000-15,000, sheltering nearly 10,000 people in 32 buildings he declared as Swedish extraterritorial property with signs like “Swedish Library” and “Swedish Research Institute.”
His methods combined document creation with dramatic personal intervention. He personally climbed onto deportation trains to hand protective passes through windows. He pursued Arrow Cross death marches to rescue certificate holders. When fascists threatened a Swedish-protected building, he confronted them: “If you want to take them, you’ll have to shoot me first.” He met Adolf Eichmann directly at a dinner party, where Eichmann warned that “even a neutral diplomat could meet with an accident.”
When Soviet forces liberated Budapest, more than 100,000 Jews remained alive, largely due to Wallenberg and colleagues’ efforts. The Swedish diplomat was detained by Soviet forces on January 17, 1945 and disappeared into the Gulag, reportedly dying July 17, 1947 in Moscow’s Lubyanka Prison—though witness reports claimed sightings into the 1980s. He received posthumous honorary citizenship from the United States, Canada, Israel, and Australia.
Varian Fry and the Emergency Rescue Committee
American journalist Varian Fry directed clandestine rescue operations from Marseille during 1940-1941 that saved approximately 2,000-4,000 refugees including Hannah Arendt, Marc Chagall, Max Ernst, André Breton, and Arthur Koestler. His operation combined document forgery with escape route development, smuggling, and bribery.
Fry arrived August 4, 1940 with $3,000 taped to his leg and a list of 200 names. He established the cover organization “Centre Américain de Secours” and assembled a remarkable team: Mary Jayne Gold, a wealthy American heiress who conducted interviews and served as courier; Daniel Bénédite, a former French police officer; and crucially, Willi Spira, a Viennese cartoonist who falsified credentials. Hans and Lisa Fittko served as mountain guides for Pyrenees crossings, while U.S. diplomat Hiram “Harry” Bingham IV supplied visas in defiance of State Department instructions.
The network forged passports and visas, organized black-market fund exchanges, smuggled refugees on French troopships, and developed escape routes over the Pyrenees to Spain and onward. They coordinated with multiple consuls—Mexican, Brazilian, Siamese, Lithuanian, Cuban, and Panamanian—to obtain exit documentation. The villa Air-Bel housed staff and some refugees during operations.
Fry operated under constant Vichy police surveillance, enduring repeated raids, arrests, and interrogations while violating both French and American government regulations. The State Department actively opposed his work. He was expelled from France on September 6, 1941 after 13 months. In 1996, Yad Vashem recognized him as the only American Righteous Among the Nations, and in 2000, the square before the U.S. consulate in Marseilles was renamed Place Varian Fry. Secretary of State Warren Christopher officially apologized for the State Department’s earlier treatment of Fry.
British counterfeiting in the American Revolution
The American Revolutionary War produced the most documented example of state-sponsored counterfeiting as explicit economic warfare policy. The British government, operating primarily from British-controlled New York City under General Henry Clinton’s personal oversight, systematically counterfeited Continental currency from 1775-1783.
The operation ran openly: the New York Gazette in April 1777 advertised for people willing to distribute counterfeit Continental currency, offering “any number of counterfeit notes” to travelers entering rebel colonies. The American frigate Deane captured the British ship Glencairn in 1779 carrying specialized counterfeiting materials including paper with silk and mica flakes. Distribution networks employed Loyalist civilians, British prisoners of war (notably after General Burgoyne’s surrender), and deserters returning to Patriot territory with counterfeit bills.
Benjamin Franklin, who had developed innovative nature-print currency using leaf impressions as anti-counterfeiting features, later wrote that “immense quantities of these counterfeits which issued from the British government in New York were circulated among the inhabitants of all the states, before the fraud was detected.” At some points, counterfeit currency may have exceeded legitimate currency in circulation.
A captured letter from General Clinton to Lord Germaine dated January 30, 1780 explicitly confirmed official policy: “No experiments suggested by your Lordship; no assistance that could be drawn from the power of gold, or the arts of counterfeiting, have been left unattempted.” Published in the Pennsylvania Journal on April 8, 1780, this letter provided documentary proof of British government sanction.
The campaign contributed significantly to economic instability. By 1781, the exchange rate reached $225 paper to $1 in hard currency. George Washington wrote that “a wagon-load of money will scarcely purchase a wagon-load of provisions.” John Adams warned his wife to be “very wary of taking any paper money.” The phrase “not worth a Continental” entered American English. In 1780, Congress recalled entire currency issues due to extensive counterfeiting. Post-war economic devastation contributed to Shays’ Rebellion (1786-87) and the push for stronger central government under the Constitution.
The Underground Railroad’s borrowed papers
The Underground Railroad, operating from approximately the 1780s through 1863, helped an estimated 100,000-500,000 enslaved people escape to freedom. Document forgery and strategic “borrowing” of papers proved essential to this movement.
Free Black people in slave states were required to carry Freedom Papers or Certificates of Freedom—legal documents proving free status. Protection Papers or Seamen’s Protection Certificates certified American citizenship for sailors, which Black sailors used to prove free status. Manumission Documents documented emancipation by slaveholders. These papers could be borrowed, forged, or strategically shared among those who physically resembled each other closely enough to pass inspection.
Frederick Douglass’s 1838 escape exemplified the borrowing strategy. He used protection papers from a free Black sailor to travel from Maryland to New York. As Douglass later explained: “A slave nearly or sufficiently answering the description set forth in the papers, would borrow or hire them till he could by their means escape to a free state, and then, by mail or otherwise, return them to the owner.” This created enormous risk for lenders—discovery could result in their own re-enslavement. Douglass described it as “an act of supreme trust on the part of a freeman of color thus to put in jeopardy his own liberty that another might be free.”
Maryland’s 1805 law specifically addressed “great mischiefs… from slaves coming into possession of certificates of free Negroes.” Descriptions on papers were often deliberately vague, allowing multiple people to use the same documents. Runaway slave notices in newspapers frequently reported that freedom seekers were using forged papers. Organizations including the New York Committee of Vigilance (founded 1835) and Vigilant Association of Philadelphia coordinated escapes and document procurement.
North Korea’s superdollar program and modern state counterfeiting
Since the late 1980s, North Korea has allegedly produced high-quality counterfeit $100 bills called “supernotes”—counterfeits so sophisticated they are described as “nearly indistinguishable from real money.” The U.S. Secret Service estimates $45 million in superdollars have been detected since 1989.
The operation allegedly uses the same intaglio printing process as the U.S. Bureau of Engraving and Printing, with paper produced on cotton/linen blend replicating security features. The leading theory suggests East German factories producing fake documents smuggled equipment to North Korea before the Berlin Wall fell in 1989. The program is reportedly overseen by “Room 39,” the Kim regime’s slush fund organization.
Distribution allegedly occurs through diplomatic channels, with diplomats receiving counterfeit mixed with real dollars at a 1:1 ratio. Seán Garland of the Official IRA was reportedly tracked traveling to Moscow’s North Korean embassy, allegedly laundering supernotes through Dublin and Birmingham. In 2009, the Korean Workers’ Party External Liaison Department reportedly sold supernotes to Nigerian buyers for 30% of face value.
The purposes serve multiple strategic goals: economic warfare against the United States, funding for nuclear and missile programs, financing regime activities, and sanctions evasion. However, challenges to the narrative exist—the Swiss Bundeskriminalpolizei has expressed doubt about North Korean origin, and by 2008 the U.S. reportedly no longer explicitly accused the North Korean government of producing supernotes. British academic Hazel Smith has argued the allegations have weak foundations.
Criminal versus political counterfeiting: the crucial distinction
Historical and legal frameworks consistently distinguish between criminal counterfeiting for profit and politically motivated counterfeiting as resistance. Counterfeiting was historically “regarded as a form of treason against the State or Crown rather than as a simple crime”—punishments including burning at the stake and drawing and quartering reflected its political nature.
The National Research Council’s 2006 report “Is That Real?” classified counterfeiters into five categories: primitive (manual artistry for gain), hobbyists (occasional, desktop equipment), petty criminals (dedicated, specialized equipment), professional criminals (organized groups, sophisticated production), and state-sponsored counterfeiters (using same equipment as governments, “profit may be secondary,” “minimally deterred by banknote features”). The report concluded that “other deterrence methods, including law enforcement and political pressure, are required” for state-sponsored operations.
Resistance forgers consistently operated under different ethical frameworks than criminal counterfeiters. Adolfo Kaminsky never accepted payment precisely to maintain moral clarity and independence. The distinction matters because politically motivated counterfeiting serves collective liberation goals rather than individual enrichment, operates within broader resistance movements rather than criminal enterprises, accepts extraordinary personal risk for ideological rather than financial reward, and often involves forging documents (identity papers, travel permits) rather than currency.
The Dutch resistance and impossible identity cards
The Netherlands presents a particularly instructive case study because the Dutch identity card (persoonsbewijs), designed by Jacob Lentz, was considered nearly impossible to forge. It required passport photos and fingerprints, featured three watermarks, and connected to a central registry for cross-checking—more advanced than any other occupied European country’s ID system.
Despite these obstacles, forgers succeeded. Alice Cohn, a German Jewish graphic artist in hiding near Utrecht, spent two years in an attic forging “wild papers” including ID and ration cards. Working with the Utrecht-based resistance group, she saved up to 350 Jewish children. The contrast between Cohn (the Jewish forger) and Lentz (the Dutch bureaucrat who designed the system) exemplifies what Hannah Arendt called the “banality of evil”—Lentz’s technical innovation enabled persecution while Cohn’s technical resistance undermined it.
The resistance group led by painter Willem Arondeus and conductor Frieda Belinfante—both Jewish, both gay—created fake identity cards before executing their most dramatic operation: bombing the Amsterdam Central Records Office on March 27, 1943 to destroy duplicate records used to verify identity cards. Arondeus was executed; Belinfante escaped to Switzerland.
German Wehrmacht soldier Werner Klemke, a talented artist who despised Nazism, risked his life forging identity cards, baptismal certificates, and birth certificates for Dutch Jews. His work enabled Jews to leave Holland or go into hiding. He operated through the resistance network of Sam and Gerard van Perlstein.
East German escape networks and the Berlin Wall
Between 1961 and 1989, “Fluchthelfer” (escape helpers) organized escapes from East Germany using forged documents alongside tunnels, hidden vehicle compartments, and hot air balloons. The Tunnel 57 operation in 1964—the largest successful tunnel escape—allowed 57 people to reach the West.
Engineering student Joachim Neumann escaped in 1961 using a borrowed Swiss student passport, then helped organize Tunnel 57. Hasso Herschel smuggled approximately 1,000 East Germans to the West over years using various methods including forged West German and Swiss passports. NBC television funded Tunnel 29 construction in exchange for filming rights—unusual media involvement in escape operations.
The risks were severe: 138 people officially died attempting to escape across the Berlin Wall, with up to 1,100 deaths on the entire inner German border. The “Schießbefehl” (order to shoot) authorized border guards to kill escapees. Fifty thousand East Germans faced prison or internal exile for helping escapees, with escape helpers receiving average 5-year sentences if caught.
The 1980s Sanctuary Movement
The Sanctuary Movement of the 1980s demonstrates how document assistance for refugees continued into the modern era. Over 500 congregations—Lutheran, Catholic, Methodist, Baptist, Jewish, Unitarian, Quaker, and Mennonite—sheltered Central American refugees fleeing violence in El Salvador and Guatemala.
Jim Corbett (Quaker) and Rev. John Fife (Southside Presbyterian Church, Tucson) established the movement in March 1982, creating an “Underground Railroad” style network to transport refugees from Mexico through the U.S. to Canada. Canadian Quaker Nancy Pocock established a parallel “overground railway.” At its peak in 1986, over 300 churches openly sponsored undocumented refugees.
Some congregations provided forged identification papers alongside shelter, legal advice, and material support. The government infiltrated the movement with informants, leading to the 1985-1986 prosecution of 16 Tucson leaders—8 were convicted and received suspended sentences for conspiracy and alien-smuggling.
The movement’s outcomes proved lasting: it contributed to Temporary Protected Status legislation in 1990, the American Baptist Churches v. Thornburgh settlement protecting Central Americans in 1991, and laid groundwork for modern sanctuary city policies. By 2018, over 1,150 congregations endorsed sanctuary.
Economic and psychological impact on target regimes
Counterfeiting’s effectiveness operates on multiple levels. Economic disruption occurs when counterfeit currency increases money supply without corresponding productivity, potentially triggering inflation, eroding purchasing power, and undermining confidence in monetary systems. The British counterfeiting of Continental currency contributed to the phrase “not worth a Continental” and exchange rates of $225 paper to $1 hard currency.
Psychological warfare compounds economic effects. When populations cannot trust their currency or documentation systems, institutional legitimacy erodes. Operation Bernhard forced Britain to redesign its entire currency system—a tangible victory even without achieving hyperinflation. The post-war Bank of England took over a decade to restore higher-denomination notes.
Resource diversion matters tactically. Regimes must devote personnel, technology, and funds to detecting counterfeits, redesigning security features, and prosecuting forgers. Every official examining documents is an official not doing something else. The Dutch resistance’s destruction of registry records forced the occupation to rebuild verification systems.
Humanitarian impact from document forgery operates differently—measuring success in lives saved rather than economic damage inflicted. Kaminsky’s 10,000-14,000 lives saved, Wallenberg’s contribution to 100,000 survivors in Budapest, and Varian Fry’s 2,000-4,000 rescued refugees represent counterfeiting’s most unambiguously positive outcomes.
Factors determining success or failure
Historical analysis reveals consistent patterns in counterfeiting operations’ effectiveness:
Technical capability proved essential—Station XIV’s 275,000 documents and Operation Bernhard’s Bank of England-quality notes required exceptional expertise. Kaminsky’s lactic acid breakthrough enabled document alterations previously impossible. Alice Cohn’s success against the “impossible” Dutch ID system required creative adaptation.
Network integration separated successful operations from isolated efforts. Forged documents without distribution channels, safe houses, corrupt officials, and escape routes held limited value. Varian Fry’s operation succeeded because it combined document production with mountain guides, black-market funding, and multiple consular connections.
Security practices determined survival. SOE Station XIV operated in compartmentalized cells so that if one was captured, others survived. Kaminsky’s solo laboratory minimized exposure. The Underground Railroad’s decentralized structure prevented single-point failures.
Strategic clarity distinguished effective operations. British counterfeiting of Continentals had clear objectives: economic destabilization and undermining Congressional legitimacy. Operation Bernhard’s shifting goals—from mass distribution to intelligence funding—reflected strategic uncertainty. The most effective humanitarian operations maintained singular focus: saving lives.
Duration of need affected outcomes. Short-term operations to help specific refugees could succeed with limited resources. Long-term economic warfare required sustained production capacity. Kaminsky’s 30-year career demonstrated extraordinary sustained commitment.
The connection to broader resistance campaigns
Counterfeiting never operates effectively in isolation. Operation Bernhard supported intelligence operations and military rescue missions. Dutch resistance forgery enabled hiding networks that sheltered 200,000 families. French Resistance document work facilitated guerrilla operations, escape lines, and Jewish rescue networks. The Sanctuary Movement combined document assistance with legal advocacy, public sanctuary declarations, and political organizing.
Gene Sharp’s classification of counterfeiting as Method #90 under “economic interventions” places it within a broader framework of nonviolent action. Sharp analyzed 198 methods across categories including protest, non-cooperation, and intervention. Counterfeiting functions as intervention—active disruption of opponent systems rather than mere refusal to cooperate.
The most effective historical applications combined counterfeiting with multiple other methods: the Dutch resistance combined forgery with armed action, underground publishing, and mass hiding of refugees. The Sanctuary Movement combined document assistance with public civil disobedience, church sanctuary declarations, and political lobbying. The Underground Railroad combined forged papers with safe house networks, guide systems, and coordinated transportation.
This integration matters strategically because counterfeiting alone rarely achieves decisive outcomes. British counterfeiting contributed to Continental currency collapse but did not prevent American independence. Operation Bernhard disrupted British currency systems but did not alter the war’s outcome. Document forgery saved thousands of individual lives within contexts where broader resistance—military, political, and social—ultimately achieved liberation.
